“3.2 featuring Robert Berry: the highlight of the [ProgStock Festival] weekend…..Berry and his band are well drilled, with Colyer’s keyboard mastery in particular impressing, and deserve greater prominence.” – PROG Magazine Issue 104

Circuline’s CD/DVD/Blu-ray CircuLive::Majestik – “…detours into ELP territory via Colyer’s organ solo…” – PROG magazine, Issue 88

Circuline’s CD/DVD/Blu-ray CircuLive::Majestik – “Colyer’s ubiquitous symphonic keys…Emerson-esque flourishes…” – Progression magazine, Issue 74

“Colyer’s dominant keyboards are excellent throughout [Circuline’s second album Counterpoint], recalling Keith Emerson particularly…” – Classic Rock Society magazine, Issue 215

“Circuline promote themselves as “Modern Cinematic Progressive Rock” and certainly Colyer’s tasteful piano and lush keyboard orchestrations go someway to justifying that claim. I was reminded of one time Simple Minds keyboardist Mick MacNeil (I wonder what became of him) while the strident organ and noodly synth breaks recall the late, great Keith Emerson. This is especially apparent in the longer songs like Hollow featuring an instrumental sequence that tips its hat to ELP’s Tarkus.”  –Geoff Feakes, Dutch Progressive Rock Page, Issue 2018-055


“A spotlight on Colyer’s Keith Jarrett-like melodic fluidity” – Geoff Wilbur’s Music Blog [review of Circuline’s album Counterpoint]

“Colyer’s solo piano sections with their suggestions of Keith Emerson. The full-on instrumental is pure Tarkus” – Jez Rowden, The Progressive Aspect [review of Circuline’s album Counterpoint]

 Andrew Colyer’s keyboard work throughout the album is exceptional (the last half of “Summit” reminds me of 70’s ELP). – Thomas Hatton, Proglodytes [review of Circuline’s album Counterpoint]


Tony Levin (Peter Gabriel, King Crimson) – “Some of this sounds like YES.”

Jon Anderson (YES) – “Great…..beautiful music.”

Geoff Downes (YES, Asia) – “Very good…you’ve got the Prog Rock chops.”

Robert Berry (Keith Emerson, Carl Palmer, Steve Howe, Ambrosia) – “Spectacular keyboard player.”

David Rosenthal (Billy Joel, Cyndi Lauper, Robert Palmer, Rainbow) – “Great playing… especially the ELP stuff!  Super cool.”

Dave Medd (The Tubes) – “Great keyboard player – he’s a bad-ass!”

Frank Wyatt (Happy the Man, Oblivion Sun) – “Andrew, I really love your keyboards on “The Approach”.  I find myself listening to it again and again, which is unusual for me as I usually don’t revisit recordings very often once they are completed. You did a remarkable job, and I cannot thank you enough for the hard work and excellent performance.  Peace Brother.”

Chris Clark (Brand X, Virgil Donati) – “You have done the equivalent of being the Wright Brothers at Kitty Hawk, to going to the moon, in just a few short years!  Great job!”

Bill Brasso (Oblivion Sun, Cell15, Frank Wyatt) – “Andrew’s playing is fantastic!  He’s like a combination of Rick Wakeman, Tony Banks, and Keith Emerson.  My new nickname for him is Emer-Bank-Man.”

Fred Schendel (Glass Hammer) – “You were great!”

Glenn Dagrossa (Awaken) – “You have made everything sound better.  All of my songs just got a B12 shot!”

Rian Adkinson – “Dude, what you did on ‘Impossible’ was just beautiful!  You made the song sound better!”

Paul Ilsley (10th Planet, Kinetic Punch) – “Stupendous player.”

Dave Ostrowski (Downing Grey) – “Freaking monster on keyboards.”

Brook Hansen (Prog Rock Orchestra) – “He’s a wizard…the ‘Proggiest’ moment of the entire show is [Andrew’s] solo.”


“Watching you blow the roof off the house with 3.2 featuring Robert Berry [at the 2019 ProgStock Festival].  Dude, you were on fire!” – Ed Mulhall, Florida

On Andrew’s solo work:

“Your musical talent and choice of what you play…will continue to bring joy to me and to many others.”  –Serita W., Rhinebeck, New York

“I’ve listened to your Christmas Time CD nonstop in my car for the past four weeks straight!  I haven’t listened to anything else.  I’ve been so stressed for the past several years being the caretaker for a quadraplegic, and now that it’s over, I’m just trying to unwind from that chronic tense situation.  Your music has helped me so much.  I know you’re doing what you’re supposed to be doing to give back to people.  Thank you!” — Michelle Fortney, RN, Catskill, New York